Low-dose fish oil therapy
effective in IgA nephropathy
ROCHESTER, MINNESOTA. IgA
nephropathy is a fairly common
kidney disorder. It is caused by an
inflammation (glomerulonephritis) in
the network of blood capillaries
involved in the filtration of waste
products from the blood. More
specifically, it manifests itself
through the deposit of the antibody
immunoglobulin A (IgA) in the
mesangial cells, which support the
walls of the capillaries. The IgA
deposits and accompanying lesions to
the capillaries interfere with
proper filtration of waste products
from the blood. IgA nephropathy is
more common in men than in women and
its incidence peaks between the ages
of 16 and 35 years. IgA nephropathy
is associated with a gradual decline
in kidney function leading to
end-stage renal disease within 5 to
25 years of diagnosis in 20-40% of
patients. The disease is usually
diagnosed after blood or excess
protein is observed in the urine.
Serum creatinine levels are
abnormally high in IgA nephropathy
because the kidneys are unable to
filter creatinine (a waste byproduct
of creatine, a protein that supplies
energy for muscle contraction) out
of the blood and excrete it in the
urine. A doubling in serum
creatinine level corresponds to a
50% decline in kidney function.
There are no pharmaceutical drugs
that will slow down or reverse the
progression of IgA nephropathy.
Researchers at the Mayo Clinic
previously reported that
supplementation with 1.9 grams/day
of EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid) plus
1.4 grams/day of DHA (docosahexaenoic
acid) is effective in retarding the
progression of IgA nephropathy. The
researchers have now carried out
another clinical trial to determine
whether doubling the daily dose of
fish oil supplement would be even
more effective. Their randomized
clinical trial involved 73 patients
with biopsy-diagnosed IgA
nephropathy. Ten of the patients had
quite severe disease as indicated by
a baseline serum creatinine level of
3.0-4.9 mg/dL while the remaining 63
patients had moderate disease (serum
creatinine between 1.5-2.9 mg/dL).
The fish oil supplement used in the
trial was supplied by Pronova in
Norway (trade name – Omacor)
in the form of highly purified ethyl
esters of EPA and DHA.
At the end of the 2-year study
period the serum creatinine level in
the low-dose group (1.9 g/day of EPA
plus 1.5 g/day of DHA) had increased
by 0.08 mg/dL per year while
patients in the high-dose group (3.8
g/day of EPA plus 3.0 g/day of DHA)
saw an average yearly increase of
0.10 mg/dL. Rapid deterioration in
kidney function (creatinine increase
of more than 0.5 mg/dL per year) was
observed in 70% of the patients with
severe disease as compared to only
23% in the group with moderate
disease. There was no significant
difference in the number of patients
in the low and high dose groups who
developed end-stage renal disease (ESRD).
At the end of 2 years 86% in the
low-dose group and 80% in the
high-dose group were still free of
ESRD. The corresponding numbers
after 3 years were 73% and 76%. The
2-year number of about 85% ESRD-free
compares to only 63% ESRD-free in a
previously investigated placebo
group.
The Omacor supplement was
generally well-tolerated, but two
patients (out of 73) did discontinue
their treatment as a result of
gastrointestinal intolerance. There
were no unfavourable effects on
serum lipid profiles (cholesterol
levels), hematocrits, peripheral
blood leucocytes or platelets. The
researchers conclude that low- dose
and high-dose fish oil
supplementation is equally effective
in slowing the progression of IgA
nephropathy.
Donadio, JV, et al. A randomized
trial of high-dose compared with
low-dose omega-3 fatty acids in
severe IgA nephropathy. Journal of
the American Society of Nephrology,
Vol. 12, 2001, pp. 791-99
MSG implicated in fibromyalgia
GAINESVILLE, FLORIDA.
Fibromyalgia is the third most
commonly diagnosed rheumatologic
disorder (after osteoarthritis and
rheumatoid arthritis). It affects
mostly women with an average age of
onset of between 29 and 37 years and
diagnosis most often made between
the ages of 34 and 53 years. It is
estimated that fibromyalgia affects
between 3 and 6 million people in
the USA alone. The disorder is
characterized by fatigue, morning
stiffness, sleep disturbances, and
widespread pain and tenderness.
Pharmacists at the University of
Florida believe that monosodium
glutamate (MSG) and aspartame
(NutraSweet) are the underlying
causes of fibromyalgia in a subset
of patients. They describe 4 cases
where patients completely eliminated
their fibromyalgia and accompanying
disorders by adhering to a diet free
of MSG and aspartame. The symptoms
reappeared when MSG was reintroduced
into the diet and disappeared again
when eliminated. The 4 patients were
all women who had suffered from
fibromyalgia for anywhere from 2 to
17 years. They all suffered from
numerous other conditions including
irritable bowel syndrome, carpal
tunnel syndrome, allergic rhinitis
(hay fever), TMJ, GERD, anxiety,
depression, and headaches. All of
these symptoms disappeared within a
couple of months after MSG and
aspartame were eliminated from the
diet. One patient was able to reduce
her number of medications from 15 to
1.
MSG is, unfortunately, an
extremely common ingredient in most
processed foods. It is also known
under the aliases of gelatin,
hydrolyzed vegetable protein,
textured protein, and yeast
extracts. Eliminating it and
aspartame from the diet requires
constant vigilance.
The researchers point out that
MSG was classified as safe by the
FDA in 1959. Because of its long
history of "safe" usage it was
approved automatically before new
stringent test requirements for food
additives went into effect in 1958.
The researchers question the safety
of MSG and suggest that much of the
research performed to prove its
safety for human consumption may
have been flawed. Both MSG and
aspartame are now known to be potent
neurotoxins (excitatory amino acids)
and can affect the body through
their action on central NMDA (N-
methyl-D-aspartame) receptors and
through the inappropriate release of
pituitary hormones into the general
circulation. The Florida pharmacists
urge large scale clinical trials to
further explore the connection
between fibromyalgia and MSG and
aspartame, but do point out that not
all fibromyalgia patients may be
sensitive to the two food additives.
Smith, JD, et al. Relief of
fibromyalgia symptoms following
discontinuation of dietary
excitotoxins. Annals of
Pharmacotherapy, Vol. 35, June 2001,
pp. 702-06
Melatonin improves sleep
BERLIN, GERMANY. Whether or not
melatonin improves sleep pattern is
a subject of controversy. A team of
Dutch and German researchers now
weigh in with a new study that
clearly shows that melatonin
increases the duration of
rapid-eye-movement (REM) sleep and
helps alleviate disorders associated
with disturbed REM sleep. The
double-blind, placebo-controlled,
parallel design study involved 5
women and 9 men with an average age
of 50 years who suffered from
reduced REM sleep duration and
neuropsychiatric sleep disorders
such as narcolepsy (daytime
sleepiness), restless leg syndrome,
insomnia, and periodic limb movement
disorder. The participants took
placebo or a 3-mg melatonin capsule
as closely as possible to their
normal bedtime, but always between
the hours of 2200 and 2400 (10 p.m.
to midnight) every night for 4 weeks
and were then assigned to the
opposite treatment after a 1-week
washout period.
The researchers found that
patients in the melatonin group
increased the duration of their REM
sleep by about 20% and also showed a
significant drop in minimum rectal
temperature during the night. Eleven
out of 14 patients reported clear
improvements in their symptoms
during melatonin treatment. Nine
reported reduced daytime fatigue, 8
reported a stronger sense of feeling
refreshed after awakening in the
morning, and 8 reported increased
sleepiness in the evening. None of
the participants reported any side
effects or changes in frequency,
content, intensity or quality of
their dreams. Of particular interest
was the finding that the beneficial
effect of melatonin lasted will
beyond the time period in which the
supplement was actually taken. In
other words, once the circadian
pacemaker is reset it remains this
way for weeks or months after
melatonin supplementation is
discontinued. The researchers point
out that it is crucial to keep the
timing of melatonin administration
constant. They also warn that
melatonin may have undesirable
long-term effects and should not be
used for extended periods of time,
except under the supervision of a
physician.
Kunz, D, et al. Melatonin in
patients with reduced REM sleep
duration. Journal of Clinical
Endocrinology & Metabolism, Vol. 89,
January 2004, pp. 128-34 |